“Your reports are normal.” Few sentences bring more relief. You fold the paper, put it in a drawer and get on with life. But imagine two friends, both slim, both with fasting sugar in the normal range. Five years later, one is diagnosed with type 2 diabetes and fatty liver. The other is fine. Same weight, same normal report, very different futures. How?
The answer lies in an idea called the personal fat threshold. Once you understand it, you will read every lab report a little differently. And you will be able to explain it to anyone who has a water tank on their roof.
What is the personal fat threshold?
Your body stores fat in a safe place: under the skin, around the hips, thighs and arms. This is subcutaneous fat, the body’s proper storage cupboard. Researchers Roy Taylor and Rury Holman (2015) proposed that each person has a personal ceiling for how much fat this safe store can hold. Below your ceiling, extra fat is tucked away harmlessly. Above it, fat spills into places it does not belong: the liver, the muscles and the pancreas.
Fat inside the liver causes fatty liver and makes the liver resist insulin, the hormone that moves sugar out of the blood. Fat in the muscles makes them stop answering insulin’s knock. Fat in the pancreas slowly hampers the very cells that make insulin. That is the road to type 2 diabetes.
The key word is personal. Your ceiling is not your neighbour’s. It is set partly by genes, partly by ancestry, and partly by what has been happening to your body for years.
The overflowing water tank
Think of the overhead water tank on a Kolkata rooftop. Some houses have a big tank, some a small one. The motor runs, the tank fills, and nobody thinks about it. Then one day the tank is full and water pours out of the overflow pipe, down the wall and onto the neighbour’s balcony.
Your safe fat store is that tank. Food energy beyond what you use is the water from the motor. While the tank has room, nothing seems wrong. Once it is full, the overflow goes to your liver and pancreas. And here is the crucial point: the overflow happens at the tank’s limit, not at a particular body weight. A small tank overflows sooner. A slim person with a small tank can overflow at a weight that looks perfectly healthy on the scale.
Why thin people still get diabetes
This explains something almost every Indian family has seen: the thin uncle with diabetes. South Asians often develop type 2 diabetes at lower body weights than people of European origin. One reasonable explanation is a smaller safe store, a smaller tank, so fat overflows into the liver and pancreas earlier, often while the person still looks slim. The only outside clue may be a slowly thickening waist, as fat settles deep around the organs rather than under the skin.
A small but telling study supports this. In ReTUNE (Taylor, 2023), 20 people with type 2 diabetes and a BMI under 27, so not obese by the usual yardstick, went through repeated cycles of about 5 percent weight loss. About 70 percent reached remission (sugar below the diabetes range without diabetes medicines) after losing around 6.5 percent of their weight. Their liver fat and fasting insulin returned to normal, though the insulin response after meals did not. Even in slim people, a little overflow mattered.
The larger DiRECT trial (Lean, 2018, 306 people) showed the same logic. Remission at 12 months tracked weight lost: 7 percent of those who lost under 5 kg, 34 percent at 5 to 10 kg, 57 percent at 10 to 15 kg and 86 percent at 15 kg or more. Those who gained weight had none. Remission is not a cure, and it needs ongoing medical supervision, but the pattern shows that lowering the level in the tank matters.
A lab value is a tank level, not a rate
The tank helps in another way. A blood result such as fasting glucose is a concentration: how much is in the blood at that moment. It reflects how much is produced minus how much is cleared. It is like glancing at the water level in the tank. The level can look steady while the motor roars and the outlet works twice as hard to keep up.
That is exactly what happens in the years before diabetes. In the Whitehall II study (Tabak, 2009), which followed 6,538 civil servants, fasting glucose sat at 5.79 mmol/L thirteen years before diagnosis, inside the normal range. Over those years, insulin sensitivity fell and the pancreas pushed out more insulin to keep glucose looking normal. Only when the pancreas began to tire did glucose climb to 7.40 at diagnosis. The routine test showed a calm level while the system strained beneath it.
So “normal” means the level is fine today. It does not tell you how hard your body is working to keep it there.
What quietly lowers your ceiling
Cortisol, the stress hormone
Long-term stress, poor sleep and night shifts keep cortisol high. Cortisol tends to move fat from the safe store under the skin to the unsafe store deep in the belly and around the organs. It is like someone quietly swapping your roof tank for a smaller one while you sleep.
Inflammation
Low-grade inflammation is a smouldering response the body keeps running in the background, and it often moves before sugar does. In a large study of nearly 28,000 women (Pradhan, 2001), those with the highest levels of CRP, a blood marker of inflammation, had about four times the risk of developing diabetes, even with HbA1c at 6.0 percent or lower, a level most people would call safe.
“The alarm has not gone off” is not a seatbelt
A silent smoke alarm tells you there is no smoke at the sensor right now. It does not tell you the wiring is safe. A normal glucose report works the same way. It is the absence of an alarm, not a form of protection.
The BFLL way of thinking is to look beneath the number to the root cause, and to test, not guess. So the better questions are: where is my ceiling, and what is quietly lowering it? Two simple measures speak much earlier than glucose:
- Read your waist. A growing waist often means the tank is overflowing, even when your weight looks fine.
- Ask for a fasting insulin. High insulin with normal glucose means the pancreas is working overtime to hold the level steady.
From there, the work is to lower the level in the tank and protect your ceiling: Therapeutic Strength Training to build muscle, which is a large and healthy store for blood sugar; nutrition guided by NOCC, the Nutrient Over Calorie Concept; better sleep and stress care; and re-testing to see whether the numbers have truly moved.
What you can start this week
- Measure your waist at the navel and write it down.
- Ask your doctor to add fasting insulin, and CRP if it suits your situation, to your next blood test.
- Lay your old reports side by side. Is a number slowly climbing, even within normal?
- Protect seven hours of sleep for one week.
- Start two strength sessions a week at a level that suits you.
Related at BFLL: Diabetes Management at BFLL, Blood tests in Kolkata, Fat Loss Management.
Frequently asked questions
My BMI is normal. Can I still have fatty liver?
Yes. Fatty liver is seen in people with a normal BMI, particularly in South Asians. A waist measurement and a liver assessment by your doctor give a better picture than weight alone.
How do I know where my ceiling is?
No single test measures it directly. A rising waist, high fasting insulin, fatty liver on a scan or raised triglycerides (a type of blood fat) suggest the overflow has started. Your doctor can help you read these together.
If my sugar is normal, do I need to do anything?
A normal result is good news for today. If your waist is growing, diabetes runs in your family, or your fasting insulin is high, it is worth acting now, while your body is still compensating well.
Can losing weight clear fat from my liver and pancreas?
Studies such as DiRECT and ReTUNE suggest that modest, sustained weight loss can reduce fat in these organs, and some people reach remission. Results vary from person to person, and any change to diabetes medicines must be made only by your treating doctor.
Care at BFLL Wellness, Kolkata. Call or WhatsApp +91 98009 00450, or book an appointment at https://bfllwellness.com/book-an-appointment/.
BFLL Naktala (head branch): 1/183, Ground Floor, Naktala, near Naktala Udayan Sangha Club, Kolkata 700047.
BFLL Salt Lake: AD-222, Sector-I, Salt Lake, Kolkata 700064.
Medical disclaimer: This article is for education only and is not a substitute for personalised medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional before changing your treatment, diet or exercise programme.
Compiled and written by Soumick Mondal Raj, Founder and CEO of BFLL, Holistic Health Consultant.
Compiled and curated by BFLL. Last updated 18 November 2026.
Sources
- Taylor R, Holman RR. Normal weight individuals who develop type 2 diabetes: the personal fat threshold. Clin Sci. 2015;128(7):405-410. Link
- Taylor R, et al. Aetiology of type 2 diabetes in people with a ‘normal’ body mass index: testing the personal fat threshold hypothesis (ReTUNE). Clin Sci. 2023;137(16):1333-1346. Link
- Lean MEJ, et al. Primary care-led weight management for remission of type 2 diabetes (DiRECT): an open-label, cluster-randomised trial. Lancet. 2018;391:541-551. Link
- Pradhan AD, Manson JE, Rifai N, Buring JE, Ridker PM. C-reactive protein, interleukin 6, and risk of developing type 2 diabetes mellitus. JAMA. 2001;286(3):327-334. Link
- Tabák AG, et al. Trajectories of glycaemia, insulin sensitivity, and insulin secretion before diagnosis of type 2 diabetes: an analysis from the Whitehall II study. Lancet. 2009;373(9682):2215-2221. Link
